Comparisons
Melodyne to Sheet Music: What Its MIDI Export Misses
Melodyne 5 editor exports one MIDI note per audio note, and no score. What the file holds, what you still build, and the cost against $4.99 a piece.
By Antoine Duno
Updated November 17, 20268 min read

People coming from Samplab, or from a producer's Melodyne licence, ask the same thing: if it already turns piano audio into MIDI notes, is sheet music one step away? It is not. The step that is missing is the whole of notation, and Celemony's pages say so by omission. This page sets out what the export contains, what you still have to build around it, and where it makes sense to use it anyway.
This page belongs to the tools compared series, which starts with audio to MIDI converters compared. If you arrived because Samplab closed, what to do now that Samplab is offline covers your old projects, and Samplab alternatives covers the rest of the field.
Which edition can do this
Celemony sells four editions of Melodyne 5. Only some can export MIDI, and only two can read a chord.
| Edition | DNA (polyphonic) | Audio-to-MIDI | US web shop price | List price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| essential | No | No | Not listed | Not listed |
| assistant | No | Yes | US$249 | US$299 |
| editor | Yes | Yes | US$399 | US$499 |
| studio | Yes | Yes | US$699 | US$849 |
Feature columns come from Celemony's edition comparison. The assistant entry describes audio-to-MIDI as "Export the MIDI equivalent of your audio", but without DNA it cannot separate the notes of a chord, so for piano it is not the edition. The editor's listing adds "polyphonic audio-to-MIDI export". Studio adds multi-track editing on top. The editor runs on macOS and Windows as VST 3, AU, AAX or stand-alone, and Celemony's site offers a 30-day free trial of studio, so you can test on your own recording before buying.
What the MIDI file holds
Celemony's help gives two procedures. In the stand-alone version you choose File, Export. In the plug-in inside another DAW you choose Save as MIDI from the Settings menu. Both describe the result the same way: "For each audio note, a MIDI note is created with the same position, length and pitch", and "The velocity of each MIDI note is derived from the amplitude of the audio note it represents." The plug-in version exports the entire track, even when it is built from many audio segments.
That is a faithful record of what the software heard, and that is precisely the problem for sheet music. Here is what notation needs and where each item comes from.
| A score needs | In Melodyne's export? | Who supplies it |
|---|---|---|
| Pitches | Yes, one note per detected audio note | Melodyne |
| Note lengths, exactly as played | Yes | Melodyne |
| Note lengths as written values (quarter, eighth) | Not described | The notation software's quantiser |
| Loudness | Velocity from amplitude | Melodyne |
| Left and right hand | Not described | You, or MuseScore's split staff option |
| Key signature and note spelling | Not described | You |
| Time signature | Not described in the export pages | You |
| Pedal marks | Not described | You |
| Engraving (beams, ties, layout) | No | Notation software |
"Not described" means the two export pages say nothing about it, so do not count on it. The sustain pedal deserves its own note. A recording has no pedal channel, only a sound that carries on, and how that appears in MIDI depends on how the notes were detected. Our page on the sustain pedal in MIDI, CC64 explains why pedalled piano MIDI often shows long overlapping notes.
Two more caveats from the same pages. The export can leave out material: "breaths are not exported as MIDI notes" for vocals, and for material on Melodyne's rhythmic or Universal algorithms "all the MIDI notes will share the same pitch". Neither matters for piano through DNA, but the reminder that it exports what the algorithm recognised is fair.
Tempo, and rubato
MIDI to sheet music depends on knowing where the beats are. Celemony says Melodyne "is capable of recognizing not only the notes but also the prevailing tempos and time signatures within a recording". That works in the stand-alone version. The plug-in "adopts not only the audio material but also all tempo information" from the host DAW and has no tempo detection of its own, except through the ARA version.
The same page carries the warning that matters for anyone recording their own playing: it suggests leaving out "solo instruments played very freely", because they "might confuse the tempo detection". Rubato piano is exactly that. If the tempo map is wrong, the notation software will place bar lines in the wrong places, and no export setting repairs it later.
From the MIDI file to a score
Once you have the MIDI, the work moves to notation software. MuseScore Studio is free, and its handbook says it can open MIDI files, with an import setting for the shortest note value under Preferences, then Import. The detailed import panel is a different matter: MuseScore 3's handbook documents one with Quantization, Max. voices, Search tuplets, Split staff ("suited mainly for piano tracks - to assign notes to the left or right hand of the performer") and Is human performance, but the MuseScore 4 handbook page says the panel is "not currently implemented", and Studio's own page on working with MIDI is an unwritten placeholder. We have not tested Studio's import, so assume you will quantise, split hands and fix voices by hand.
Those are the choices that turn a performance into notation, whichever tool makes them, and each is one you make and check. A tight quantise grid gives readable rhythms and moves notes; a loose one keeps them and looks like a mess. We cover the ways this goes wrong in why MIDI to sheet music comes out messy, and opening audio in MuseScore shows the free route from the other side.
What Melodyne does better
It would be wrong to file Melodyne under "extra step". It has one thing a one-click converter cannot offer: you see the notes on top of the audio, and you can correct them before anything is exported. If DNA hears a wrong note, or merges two notes, you fix it against the recording you are looking at, then export. For a producer who edits audio anyway, that is a real advantage, and the MIDI is a by-product of software they already own.
It is a poor fit if the only goal is a printed score. You pay for an audio editor, you learn its note-separation tools, and you still do the notation in a second program.
The same job the other way round
Piano to Sheet Music takes the path in the opposite order. You upload a solo piano recording and get an engraved grand-staff PDF, plus MIDI and MusicXML, for $4.99 per piece with no subscription (there is a $9.99 monthly plan for unlimited pieces, if you convert a lot). The first 30 seconds of any recording are free to preview.
The trade-offs are real, so here they are side by side.
| Melodyne 5 editor | Piano to Sheet Music | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Audio editor with DNA, stand-alone and plug-in | Recording to score, in the browser |
| Price | US$399 web shop, US$499 list, one licence | $4.99 per piece, or $9.99 a month |
| What you get | MIDI, one note per audio note | Engraved PDF, MIDI, MusicXML |
| Notation | Elsewhere, by you | Included |
| Edit notes against the audio | Yes | No: you correct in notation software |
| Input | Any audio, any instrument | Solo piano audio |
| Timing in the MIDI | As played, per Celemony | Quantised, matching the PDF bar for bar |
As arithmetic only: US$399 divided by $4.99 is about 80 pieces, before counting the notation work on the Melodyne side. If you edit audio, that comparison is not the right one. If you want a score of a piece, it is.
Our own limits, since you will meet them: the tool does not write chord symbols, lyrics or lead sheets, it estimates the key signature, and it considers only 4/4, 3/4 and 6/8 for the metre. We have not measured its accuracy and do not publish a figure. Expect a draft to proofread. You can see what our MIDI export contains.
Which to choose
- You already own Melodyne, or make music in a DAW: export the MIDI, then follow the MuseScore steps above. Fix the tempo before you export.
- You need a printed or shared score of a piece: an audio to MIDI comparison will show which tools return notation and which stop at MIDI.
- You want to edit the audio and the notes together: Melodyne is the only tool in this article that does that.
Frequently asked questions
Can Melodyne turn a piano recording into sheet music?
Not by itself. Melodyne 5 editor can detect the individual notes in a polyphonic piano recording with its DNA algorithm and export them as MIDI, but the pages we read describe no notation or score output. You open the MIDI in notation software such as MuseScore and do the engraving there.
Which Melodyne edition do I need for piano?
Melodyne 5 editor or studio. Celemony's edition comparison lists DNA Direct Note Access, which is what edits polyphonic instruments such as piano, in those two only. Melodyne 5 assistant has audio-to-MIDI but not DNA, and essential has neither. In Celemony's US web shop in September 2026, editor was US$399, list US$499.
What does Melodyne's MIDI export contain?
Celemony says that for each audio note a MIDI note is created with the same position, length and pitch, and that velocity is derived from the amplitude of the audio note. Its export pages mention nothing else, such as pedal, key signature, hand assignment or notation, so do not count on any of them.
Does Melodyne detect tempo and time signature?
Yes, in the stand-alone version. Celemony says Melodyne can recognise the prevailing tempos and time signatures in a recording, but the plug-in adopts tempo information from the DAW instead. Its help also warns that solo instruments played very freely might confuse the tempo detection, which matters for rubato piano.
Is Melodyne cheaper than Piano to Sheet Music?
Only if you would use it for a lot of pieces or already need an audio editor. Melodyne 5 editor is a US$399 web shop price and you still need notation software. As arithmetic, US$399 divided by $4.99 is about 80 pieces. Piano to Sheet Music lists $4.99 for one piece (and a $9.99 monthly plan), and returns a PDF, MIDI and MusicXML.
I used Samplab. Is Melodyne the replacement?
For editing notes inside audio, it is the closest in spirit. Samplab went offline on 17 September 2026. Melodyne is a professional audio editor with a US$399 editor edition and a 30-day trial. It is not a notation tool, so its MIDI still needs turning into a score.
Sources
- Celemony: Melodyne 5 editions: DNA, audio-to-MIDI by edition
- Celemony US shop: Melodyne 5 editor: US$399 web shop, US$499 list, polyphonic audio-to-MIDI export
- Celemony US shop: all editions: assistant and studio prices
- Celemony: what is Melodyne: DNA, 30-day trial
- Melodyne 5 help: exporting MIDI, stand-alone
- Melodyne 5 help: exporting MIDI, other DAWs
- Melodyne 5 help: tempo detection and Auto Stretch
- MuseScore 3 handbook: MIDI import, MuseScore 4 handbook: MIDI import (panel "not currently implemented") and MuseScore Studio: opening and saving scores
Keep reading

Audio to MIDI Converters Compared: 7 Tools for Piano
Audio to MIDI tools compared: Basic Pitch, Piano2Notes, Songscription, AnthemScore, ScoreCloud, Melodyne and ours, from vendor pages read Sept 2026.
10 min read
Samplab Alternatives After the Shutdown: Audio to MIDI
Samplab's stated end date, 17 September 2026, has passed. What its notice says about projects and refunds, and which audio-to-MIDI tools handle piano.
9 min read
Samplab Is Offline: Open Old Projects and Move On
Samplab not working since 17 September 2026? Why logins and old versions fail, what still opens your projects, how refunds work, and where to go next.
8 min read
Can MuseScore Convert Audio or MP3 to Sheet Music?
No: MuseScore Studio opens MusicXML and MIDI, not MP3 or WAV. Transcribe the recording first, then open the MusicXML in MuseScore. The routes compared.
7 min read
How Accurate Is AI Piano Transcription? The Real Test
What piano transcription accuracy numbers measure, what a published model scored on the MAESTRO benchmark, and a test you can run on your own recording.
9 min read
Songscription vs Klangio's Piano2Notes: Price and Exports
Songscription bills minutes, Klangio's Piano2Notes counts transcriptions. Plans, prices, free tiers and exports compared from both vendors' own pages.
10 min read